American cheese wins
American cheese is on more than half of our full recipes, from Weissman’s smash burgers to the ShackBurger and Motz’s Oklahoma onion burger.
From: Joshua’s Perfect Burger, ShackBurger, Oklahoma Fried Onion Burger, Classic Diner-Style Smashed CheeseburgerKenji’s ultra-smashed recipe asks simply for “good melting cheese, such as American, cheddar, or homemade melting cheese”.
From: Ultra-Smashed Cheeseburger
Cheddar
Motz tops his green chile cheeseburger with white cheddar, and gives a choice of American or cheddar for his thick pub burger.
From: Green Chile Cheeseburger, Thick Pub Classic BurgerShredded cheddar crisps into the lacy frill of a cheese-skirt burger.
From: Cheese Skirt Burger
Swiss, blue, feta and more
Ramsay uses Swiss cheese on his backyard burger.
From: Ramsay’s Ultimate BurgerRegional and chicken burgers use cheese as a flavour: Oaxaca cheese on the cemita, blue cheese on Buffalo chicken, feta sauce on Greek chicken, goat cheese with sun-dried tomato.
From: Cemita Burger, Buffalo Chicken Burgers, Greek Chicken Burgers with Feta Sauce, Chicken Burgers with Sun-Dried Tomatoes & Goat CheeseKenji suggests pepper jack, cheddar, Muenster or Swiss on his black bean burger.
From: Black Bean Burger
How to melt it
Add it straight after the flip, or in the last minute of cooking.
From: Joshua’s Perfect Burger, Reverse Sear Burger, Thick Pub Classic BurgerCover the patty with a metal bowl or lid so the steam melts the cheese evenly (Motz).
From: Classic Smashburger “All the Way”, Thick Pub Classic Burger, Green Chile CheeseburgerOr seal it inside: the Juicy Lucy melts its cheese in the middle of the patty.
From: Juicy Lucy
Every tip above is taken from the recipe it links to. Where the experts disagree, we say so rather than picking one.